Selkirk S2 Vanguard Review

The Selkirk S2 Vanguard pickleball paddle builds on the popular S2 shape with upgraded materials and performance enhancements. Designed for players who crave precision, control, and a generous sweet spot, the Vanguard version brings new energy and a more dynamic feel compared to the original Amped line. In this review, we’ll explore how the S2 Vanguard performs, who it suits best, and how it compares to its predecessor.

Key Features of the Selkirk S2 Vanguard

The S2 Vanguard keeps the oversized face and short handle of the classic S2 but introduces Selkirk’s QuadCarbon Face and X5 Honeycomb core for improved stability and responsiveness. The result is a paddle that offers elite-level consistency and control while introducing better spin and durability.

• Dimensions: 15.75″ x 8.0″
• Weight: 7.6 – 8.4 oz (Lightweight and Midweight options)
• Core Type: X5 Honeycomb polymer core
• Surface Material: QuadCarbon (bi-directional carbon fiber)
• Grip Length: 4.5 inches
• Grip Circumference: 4.25 inches
• Shape: Standard with oversized face
• Sweet Spot: Very large and consistent
• Power Rating: Moderate
• Control Rating: High
• Spin Rating: Above average

The use of raw carbon fiber in the surface helps with spin generation and shot precision, making this a strong choice for competitive control players.

Pros and Cons

Here’s a summary of what the S2 Vanguard gets right—and where it might fall short.

Pros:

• Massive sweet spot helps reduce mishits
• Excellent touch and control for soft play
• Carbon fiber face improves spin and accuracy
• Strong build quality and premium feel
• Minimal vibration—arm friendly
• Great for single-handed strokes and blocks

Cons:

• Short grip limits two-handed backhands
• Not a top-tier power paddle
• Slightly slower hand speed compared to elongated paddles
• May feel stiff to players who prefer softer paddles
• Price point is on the higher side
• Spin is good but not elite like raw textured paddles

Built for Players Who Prioritize Control

The S2 Vanguard is all about precision. Whether you’re a seasoned control player or a developing intermediate, this paddle provides the stability and feedback needed for resets, dinks, and thoughtful ball placement. Its generous sweet spot is especially helpful during quick exchanges and defensive plays.

If you prefer soft hands and strategic placement over sheer power, the Vanguard S2 aligns beautifully with your style.

On-Court Performance and Feel

The paddle shines in the short game. The thick X5 core absorbs shock and keeps the ball on the paddle longer, allowing for better placement and fewer errors. At the net, the oversized face gives you a wider margin for error, which translates into confident blocks and counters.

The carbon fiber surface brings improved spin potential compared to the Amped’s fiberglass face. While it won’t give you raw carbon-level spin, you can shape the ball better than with older models. Its feedback is responsive but clean—ideal for resets, drop shots, and third-shot drops.

It’s not a hard-hitting paddle by any means, but the midweight version can still pack a punch when you step into your shots.

Comfort and Grip

The 4.5-inch grip is a Selkirk S2 signature—it’s great for one-handed use but may feel cramped for two-handers. The grip circumference is standard, and the handle is nicely cushioned for comfort and control.

The paddle’s weight balance feels neutral. You can swing it quickly in the kitchen, yet it still offers enough mass for reliable defense against power players.

Durability and Build Quality

Selkirk’s Vanguard line is built to last. The QuadCarbon face resists wear better than fiberglass, and the paddle’s edges and surface hold up well after long hours of play. It has a premium look and feel, and unlike some carbon-faced paddles, it doesn’t sacrifice comfort for stiffness.

That said, all paddles experience wear, and the carbon surface can lose texture over time depending on frequency of use.

Who the S2 Vanguard Is Best For

Consider the S2 Vanguard if you are:

• A control-first player who values precision over power
• A singles or doubles player who plays close to the net
• A fan of shorter handles and oversized faces
• An intermediate or advanced player who wants a responsive carbon surface
• Looking for a forgiving paddle that rewards soft touch

If you’re a spin- or power-focused player, you might prefer paddles with a longer handle and raw carbon surface. But for consistent, all-court play, the S2 Vanguard holds its own.

Final Thoughts on the Selkirk S2 Vanguard

The Selkirk S2 Vanguard is a polished, high-performance paddle that emphasizes what the original S2 did best—control, consistency, and forgiveness—while adding carbon-fiber upgrades for improved spin and feel. It’s an excellent choice for players who want to dominate the soft game with confidence and craft.

If you’re looking for a paddle that rewards smart play, helps clean up errors, and brings out your best at the kitchen line, the S2 Vanguard deserves a spot in your bag.